Review of “The Thanksgiving Play” at West End Players Guild

    The West End Players Guild is celebrating the season with a howlingly funny production of “The Thanksgiving Play,” a biting satire on well-meaning outsiders’ attempts at political correctness.

    The play is by 2020 MacArthur Fellow Larissa Fasthorse, an indigenous woman and a member of the Sicangu Lakota Nation. Because her earlier plays with indigenous characters proved difficult to cast, Fasthorse wrote “The Thanksgiving Play” for characters who are all white.

    Logan, a high school drama teacher, has received a cultural awareness grant to create an elementary school pageant celebrating Thanksgiving and Native American Heritage Month. Her collaborators in the devised work are Jaxton, her boyfriend, who is a yoga instructor and street performer; Caden, a history teacher takes pride in his research and aspires to be a playwright; and Alicia, a professional actress from Los Angeles.

    The awareness grant provided the funds to hire Alicia, who was supposed to supply a native point of view for the project. Unfortunately, Logan was wrong about Alicia’s background. She is not indigenous. Rather, she takes advantage of her ethnically ambiguous looks to be cast a variety of minority parts. Concerned about her job security, Logan goes through the mental gymnastics required to proceed with the project without an indigenous voice.

    Despite the best of intention, Logan and crew continually hamstring themselves in their quest to avoid giving offence and produce a culturally sensitive script.

    The West End production features excellent performances in a consistently broad comic style under Dani Mann’s astute direction. Colleen Backer finds the humor in Logan’s desperate effort to complete the play. W. Smith III has great fun with Jaxton’s ego-driven excesses. Chuck Winning brings wonderful physical comedy to Caden’s pursuit of his most cherished dreams. Chelsie Johnston displays unflappable cool as the ditzy, supremely self-involved Alicia.

    The impressive technical contributions include Mann’s costumes, Rob Lippert’s set design for a high school classroom, Nathan Schroeder’s lighting, Dan Foster’s projections, Anna Blair’s blood effects, and Katie Orr’s props.

    “The Thanksgiving Play” continues through November 22 at the Union Avenue Christian Church, 733 Union Boulevard.

    —Gerry Kowarsky, 2026

    Photo by John Lamb
    From the left: Colleen Backer as Logan, Chelsie Johnston as Alicia, Chuck Winning, and W. Smith as Jaxton in “The Thanksgiving Play.”

    Related Posts